City Substitute Teachers Are Often Denied Higher Pay for Long-term Work

Jason Vanegas, has been working as a substitute teacher in Brooklyn for the past three years (Credit: Sasha Rivers)

Jason Vanegas, has been working as a substitute teacher in Brooklyn for the past three years (Credit: Sasha Rivers)

Jason Vanegas, 25, began substitute teaching three years ago at a middle school in Gravesend, Brooklyn. Since then, he’s earned a master’s degree and full-time teaching credentials. In August, the assistant principal at the school he’d been subbing at for years called to offer him a long-term position, he said.

“In my head, I’m like OK, great,” Vanegas said. “I’m going to be a full-time teacher at this school. No, I was wrong.”

The assistant principal told him he would have his own classroom and take over for a full-time teacher who was leaving unexpectedly, but that he would only be paid as a daily substitute.

After asking the principal to be compensated as a full-time teacher, the school revoked the job offer, Vanegas said.

“I feel like it’s a very bureaucratic system,” Vanegas said. “If you’re not well aware of your rights then you’ll get taken advantage of.”

Columbia News Service spoke with more than 10 substitute teachers from all over the city for this article, in addition to other educators. Teachers, administrators, and union officials agree that underpayment of substitute teachers is a widespread problem in New York City. The Department of Education (DOE) did not respond to emailed questions before publication.

New York City substitute teachers can fall into three pay categories. O-status substitutes, who take daily assignments, earn $232.70 a day as of September 2025. Substitutes who work longer assignments — generally at least 30 consecutive days in the same classroom — might qualify for Z or Q status. Z-status pay starts at about $350 a day, while Q-status substitutes earn a full-time teacher’s salary, starting at $71,314 a year. By comparison, an O-status substitute working every day of the school calendar would only earn about $41,187.

When a substitute teacher goes into a school for a single day, they are not expected to do as much work as the teacher for whom they’re covering. For a short-term position, substitutes usually follow lesson plans left by the full-time teacher and monitor students as they do their schoolwork. However, many schools need subs for longer-term assignments, in which substitute teachers are working in the capacity of a full-time teacher, performing additional work such as grading assignments and planning lessons.

A 28-year-old art teacher, who requested anonymity due to concerns over job security, is currently trying to receive back pay for teaching she did between October and November 2025. Through the union’s grievance process, she’s asking to be paid for work that qualified her for Z-status. A fully certified teacher struggling to find work at the beginning of September 2025, she took a job at an elementary school in Manhattan covering a maternity leave vacancy with the understanding she would be offered a full-time position.

“I was aware of Z-status and that was my aim,” she said. “If I spent the 30 consecutive days [in the same classroom] I would get a pay increase. That was always my goal.”

After over a month, her position was terminated. She never received the higher Z-status pay she believes she’s owed. Her grievance remains pending.

The United Federation of Teachers (UFT) represents more than 200,000 members in the city and said that grievances over substitute pay are among their top five issues. 

“Despite relying on this vital workforce, the DOE often fails to properly pay these employees,” Alison Gendar, UFT spokesperson, said in an email. “The union therefore invests significant time and resources–whether through pending arbitration or prior bargaining–to ensure these educators are properly compensated.”

Joe Diodato earned back $6,000 in unpaid wages after going underpaid for months. In 2020, Diodato took a short-term job at an elementary school in the Bronx, but after a few days, the school administration asked him to stay for the rest of the year.

“When you’re a sub, stability really matters,” Diodato said. His story was first reported by New York Focus in 2024.

Diodato learned about the different pay categories from the UFT contract and realized he qualified for Q-status. Fearing he would be fired or blacklisted, he waited until his assignment was over to start the grievance process. By fall 2021, almost a year after he first took the position, the grievance was settled and he had his lost wages.

Diodato is now a full-time teacher, but remains concerned about working conditions for substitute teachers. 

“I’ve spoken to, easily, dozens of subs who went through what I went through,” he said.

About the author(s)

Sasha Rivers is a master's student specializing at the Stabile Center for Investigative Journalism. Prior to CJS, she served in the Peace Corps in the nation of Lesotho.